Unknown Sets
Unknown Fantasy Set 1
Found via Google. The original website is no longer available. If you have any information on this set, including more buttons from it or what the abilities are, please add to this page. They appear to have three dice and an ability notation.
Unknown hand-drawn orc and Racer
These appears to be a set prototype of some sort.
Unknown Lost Button Men Online (1.0) Sets
These sets were found in an archive of button recipes from the original Button Men Online website. These, and many others, are currently unknown to the modern Button Men community. If you have any information on any of these sets, please let the wiki know by editing this section or leaving a comment below. Several sets once in this section were partially found, including Dr. Oche, Moody Mutants, and the Avatars (now placed with the Hodgepodge buttons).
Also-Rans
- Al Gore's Internet
- Bryan
- Dukakis
- Dewey
- Dole
- Goldwater
- McGovern
- Mondale
- Nader
- Perot
- Thurmond
It Came From The 80s
(Most of this set was rediscovered on August 9th, 2022.)
Geddy Lee is still missing from this set (i.e. recipe is unknown).
Radioactive
(Most of this set was rediscovered Aug 9, 2022.)
Testing is still missing from this set (i.e. recipe is unknown).
Development BM set
Alpha (DevelopmentBM) Omega (DevelopmentBM)
Simpsons set
There are only two names from this set indicated, but one BMO player remembers the set being tested and removed.
- Homer Simpson
- Mr. Burns
Non-Set buttons
(Some of these may have been "Avatar" buttons, an underpowered version of Fanatics.)
- A (Yes, a button named A and a button named B)
- B
- bowler160
- Chicken Fried Chicken Fried Chicken Fried Rice
- Dana Huyler
- Easter Bunny
- Fladnag
- GolderOtter
- Jayseman
- Loren Peace
- manga
- Morten Harket
- Peacock
- Playtesting
- testing
Wacky Races
BMO Member Battle Cheese recalls a set based on the Wacky Races cartoon, but remembers no further details of the set.